Drowning the judge

Addiction, trauma and the superego

  • Lisa Zimmerman
  • Andrew Duncan

Abstract

This paper considers the relationship between trauma and addiction, developing the idea that the superego is a useful concept in understanding this relationship, and also useful in the treatment of people with addiction. The thesis is that in the people with addictions who have a trauma history, whether it be direct trauma or the more indirect trauma of early neglect, the trauma frequently contributes to a punitive superego and addiction is a mechanism to protect the person from feeling the pain inflicted by a punitive superego. Focus on affect tolerance, forgiveness therapy and working with guilt and shame are useful in the treatment of these clients. This paper is taken from a dissertation written as part of an MHSc in Psychotherapy completed by the first author at Auckland University of Technology. The clinical illustrations in the paper come from the work of the first author.

Author Biographies

Lisa Zimmerman

As recorded in 2007.

Lisa Zimmerman graduated with her masters in psychotherapy (honours) in March 2007. She has been a practicing therapist since November 2006 and works within a residential drug rehabilitation facility in Auckland. It was from her work with addicted clients, and noticing the high levels of shame her clients carry, that she became interested in exploring superego related issues in treatment.

Andrew Duncan

As recorded in 2007.

Andrew Duncan has been on the staff of the School of Psychotherapy at AUT since 1995. He has practiced psychotherapy since 1973 and in Auckland since 1992 when he returned after 20 years in the USA. He espouses a relational analytic model without excluding the value of other models. Superego issues have been a particular interest for a number of years as he has become more aware of his own punitive superego. Andrew is a member of NZAP, a group member of the Group-Analytic Society (London), Member of Inst. Clin. Psych.of NZPsychSoc and a registered clinical psychologist.

Published
2007-09-30
How to Cite
Zimmerman, L., & Duncan, A. (2007). Drowning the judge: Addiction, trauma and the superego. Ata: Journal of Psychotherapy Aotearoa New Zealand, 13(1), 76-91. https://doi.org/10.9791/ajpanz.2007.07