Insights from Statistical Trends and Patterns relating to Youth Justice: 1911 - 2021
Abstract
The distinctive demographic characteristics of Māori during the 20th century have significantly influenced the impact on Māori of public policy in many fields. Although the focus of this paper is on imprisonment rates, the approach may have some relevance in health, education and housing in particular. By grouping birth cohorts to quantify the experiences of five generations of Māori over the 20th century, it is possible to identify where shifts in legislation and institutional practices, particularly of the Police and the Judiciary, coincide with the generational shifts that reflect societal and demographic change. In this paper, insights into intergenerational change have been based on birth cohort experiences estimated from 1911. The paper shows that young males under 20 are now less likely to enter prison than any generation over the last 100 years. Differences remain in the likelihood of apprehension and sentencing for offending between Māori and those of European ethnicity. This has persisted regardless of justice policy as it has shifted from being strongly punitive to emphasising prevention, diversion and rehabilitation. The impact on the prison population over the next twenty years will be substantial, as it will decline and be predominantly from older age groups.
References
Ball, J. (2019) Sex, drugs, smokes and booze: What’s driving teen trends? Describing and explaining trends in adolescent sexual behaviour, cannabis use, smoking and alcohol use in the early 21st century. Doctor of Philosophy thesis, University of Otago, New Zealand.
Ball, J., Grucza, R., Livingston, M., ter Bogt, T., Currie, C. de Looze, M. (2023) The great decline in adolescent risk behaviours: Unitary trend, separate trends, or cascade? Social Science & Medicine Volume 317, January 2023, 115616
Bu, J. (1993) Some Socio-economic Implications of Shifts in Age/Cohort Structure of the Māori Population. M Soc. Sci thesis, University of Waikato, New Zealand
Castles, F. (1985). The Working Class and Welfare. Wellington and Sydney: Allen & Unwin
Cook, L. (2020). A Statistical Window for the Justice System: Putting a Spotlight on the Scale of State Custody across Generations of Māori. VUW Working paper.
Cook, L. (2021,1). Evidence for the times: a statistical perspective on the justice sector. VUW Working paper.
Cook, L. (2021,2). Examining the overrepresentation of M?ori in prisons: 1910 to 2020. VUW Working paper.
Cook, L (nd) Retirement Commission paper.
Department of Statistics (1931, 1936, 1946, 1951, 1956, 1961). Reports of Censuses of Population and Dwellings, Wellington.
Department of Statistics (1990). Trends in Imprisonment. Justice Statistics 1990.
Donnell, A. & Lovell, R. (1982). How Many Offend? A Descriptive Account of Levels of Offending in a Cohort of New Zealand Boys. Department of Social Welfare.
Douglas, E. (1977). Fertility Decline and Socio-cultural Change – The Case of the New Zealand Māori. University of Waikato Occasional Paper.
Durie, M 2005 Te Tai Tini Transformations 2025 Mason Durie Te Mata o te Tau Academy for Māori Research and Scholarship Massey University.
Fergusson, D. M., Donnell, A. & Slater, S. W. (1975) The Effects of Race and Socio-Economic Status on Juvenile Offending Statistics. Joint Committee on Young Offenders, Research Report No. 2. Wellington, NZ.
Fifield, J. & Donnell, A. (1980) Socio-Economic Status, Race, and Offending in New Zealand. An Examination of Trends in Officially Collected Statistics for the Māori and Non-Māori Populations. Joint Committee on Young Offenders, Research Report No. 6. Wellington, NZ
Garlick, T. (2012). Social Developments: An Organisational History of the Ministry of Social Development and its predecessors, 1860-2011. Steele Roberts. Wellington
Hercus, A. (1984) Ministerial direction by Minister of Social Welfare (Waikato University library).
Hunn, J.K. (1961) Report on the Department of Māori Affairs. Government Printer Wellington, NZ.
Irwin, K. et alia. (2011). Whānau Yesterday, Today, Tomorrow. Families Commission New Zealand
Jackson, M. (1987) The Māori and the Criminal Justice System a New Perspective - He Whajpaanga Hou. Policy and Research Division, Department of Justice Wellington, NZ
Justspeak (2017). Bailing out the Justice System: Reopening the Window of Opportunity.
Keddell, E. Hyslop I. (2019, 1) Ethnic inequalities in child welfare: The role of practitioner risk perceptions. Child & Family Social Work. 2019. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/cfs
Keddell, E & Hyslop, I, (2019, 2) Networked Decisions: Decision-Making Thresholds in Child Protection. The British Journal of Social Work, https://doi.org/10.1093/bjsw/bcz131
Keddell, E., Davie, G. (2018) Inequalities and Child Protection System Contact in Aotearoa New Zealand: Developing a Conceptual Framework and Research Agenda. Soc. Sci. 2018, 7, 89; doi:10.3390/socsci7060089
Kukutai T H (2007) White Mothers, Brown Children: Ethnic Identification of M?ori-European Children in New Zealand, Journal of Marriage and Family 69 (December 2007).
Lambie, I., Reil, J., Becroft, A., Allen, R. (2022) How we fail children who offend and what to do about it: ‘A breakdown across the whole system’. Auckland, NZ. The Law Foundation and the Michael & Suzanne Borrin Foundation.
Lovell, R. & Norris, M. (1990) One in Four: Offending from age ten to twenty-four in a cohort of New Zealand males. R Lovell, Marion Norris, Department of Social Welfare, New Zealand.
Mathews (1940) The Institutional Care of Dependent Children. NZCER, Wellington.
Mazengarb (1954). Report of the Special Committee on Moral Delinquency in Children and Adolescents New Zealand Government.
Ministerial Advisory Committee on a Māori Perspective for the Department of Social Welfare. (1986). Puao-te-Ata-tu (Day Break): The Report of the Ministerial Advisory Committee on a Māori Perspective for the Department of Social Welfare. Department of Social Welfare, Wellington.
Ministry of Justice, Department of Corrections & New Zealand Police. (2017). Maintaining a safe NZ and working towards a more humane and effective criminal justice system. Wellington, NZ.
Ministry of Justice (2013). Youth Crime Action Plan.
Ministry of Justice (2022) Long Term Insights Briefing (LTIB). www.justice.govt.nz/assets/Documents/Publications/14.02.2023-LTIB_Report_extended_final_v5_Web.pdf
Moffitt, T. (1993) Adolescent-limited and life-course-persistent antisocial behaviour: A developmental taxonomy. Psychological Review.
Ogawa, N. Mansor, N. Lee, S. Abrigo, M. Aris, T. (2021) Population Aging and the Three Demographic Dividends (2021) Asian Development Review, vol. 38, no. 1, pp. 32–67 https://doi.org/10.1162/adev_a_00157
Office of the Children’s Commissioner (2015) State of Care 2015.
Oranga Tamariki Evidence Centre. (2018). Youth Remand Trends: 2011/12 to 2015/16. Wellington, New Zealand: Spier, P.
Perry, B. (2019) Household incomes in New Zealand 1988 to 2018. Ministry of Social Development.
Philipp E (1946) Juvenile Delinquency in New Zealand: A Preliminary Study. NZCER, Wellington.
Pool, D I., (1977) The Maori Population of New Zealand 1769-1971. Auckland University Press.
Pool, I., Dharmalingam, A., Sceats, J. (2007) The New Zealand Family from 1840. Auckland University Press.
Pool, I., Baxendine, S. (2006) Population Trends, Convictions and Imprisonment: Demographic Divergence, Dichotomy and Diversity. Population Studies Centre No 61 February 2006
Statistics New Zealand (2005). Understanding and Working with Ethnicity Data. A technical paper.
Sutherland, Oliver. (2020). Justice and Race, Campaigns against Racism and abuse in Aotearoa New Zealand.
Schwimmer, E. (1968) The Māori People in the Nineteen-Sixties – A Symposium. Longman Paul.
Watt E (2003) A History of Youth Justice in New Zealand.
David V. Williams (2019) The continuing impact of amalgamation, assimilation and integration policies, Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand, DOI: 10.1080/03036758.2019.1677252.
Young, W. (2017) The Justice Sector: Opportunities and Challenges. Chap 14, Social Investment – A New Zealand Policy Experiment, Boston, J., Gill, D.